Holden is -A

Hello!
The Holden is -A theory...

1) This is Ali's diary entry from Pretty Little Liars Wikia. She wrote something about someone texting her they were "watching her" this mada us think of the NAT club and how they said they saw "all". 


The temporary tattoo on Holden’s arm shown in the episode The Remains of A is of an eye in a circle. Holden explains that is part of a party that changes venues, one that he saw Maya at before. Could this tattoo represent the N.A.T. club? Their name itself means “We See All”, and an eye would be a perfect representation of that, don’t you think? 
PLUS this tattoo  matches the exact same tatoo in Emily's flashback of "That Night".
PLUS this tatto it looks A LOT like the eye in the wigi board -A sent to Hanna.








2) Who hit Hanna with the car? 2x14 Through Many Dangers, Toils and Snares: There are two things Mona didn’t do during her time as A in seasons 1 & 2, assuming one of them being losing the phone then getting hit by the car. 
2x18 A Kiss Before Lying: Holden reveals a bruise to Aria, he supposedly got it in his fighting tournament. When Hanna hit A with the car, it would have left a large bruise and caused damage in a similar place.

3) 2x15 A Hot Piece Of A: Holden turned up just in time for when Mona confessed to being A. He hasn’t always been a part of the show and just turned up out of nowhere so he isn’t highly suspected. Mona’s revelation as A surely would have been planned amongst the A team and would need someone to do her dirty work. Holden also told Aria he was at fighting tournaments when they were using their “arrangement” so she could see Ezra, but only once do we know he actually fought. One time, Holden’s plans were cancelled and if he was really fighting surely the club would still have gone ahead as it’s an entire group of people. Maybe he had an A mission, specifically to spy on Aria as A would know if her plans were cancelled.


4) 2x19 The Naked Truth: Holden had a large bag of some kind of pills, he said they were pain pills when Aria asked him about it. In 3x5 That Girl Is Poison Emily finds she was drugged the night when she was taken to Alison’s grave. Holden obviously had a way of accessing medication as he was hoarding hundreds of pain pills, not a standard box of painkillers. He could have accessed the sleeping pills.

 


5)