Caleb is -A

Hello!
The Caleb is -A theory...

We don't hear a lot of people saying Caleb is -A but anything is possible in Rosewood and there are several things that make us think Caleb could be part of the -A team.

1) Black hoodie: We’ve already seen Caleb in a black hoodie, nothing happens on PLL without a reason. The girls thought it was A, but why did Caleb run after them without taking the hood off? Why did he turn off all the lights, knock over a lamp - creepy A things to do…

2) Paper bag: We've already talked about a paper bag in the Ezra is -A theory but maybe this clue was not about Ezra but Caleb. In one episode Hanna finds a brown paper bag where Caleb’s things are stashed, it has phones and money in it- they originally think that this is A’s stuff, money (Hanna’s mum’s money) and phones because A texts them, then they assume they are wrong. What if they aren’t? Caleb is DEFINITELY a tech savvy, and he plays around with phones all the time. He is so insistent on helping Hanna with things to gain her trust. We know that he was working for Jenna but, how do we know that he didn’t just blame her when he was caught rather than spilling everything, which an A character just obviously wouldn’t do..

At the end of the episode, A is shown to pull things out of a brown paper bag. Cooincidence? ….
Remember, A is someone who is unsuspecting, always around and close to the girls, all-knowing and very smart. Caleb.



3) He's tech savvy. There's no question that Caleb has skills that would highly benefit the "A" team. Is he the reason "A" is a tech wizard?

4) His suspicious beginnings. Let's not forget that Caleb first got close to Hanna to spy on her for Jenna. Could the entire relationship be a cover for other "A" activities?

5) His random absences. Yes, Caleb probably is just going to Cali to hang out with his birth mom. But it's possible his absences are about something else — something "A". 

6) His easy acceptance of what's going on. Caleb is always pushing to know more about what's going on with Hanna, but he never seems that phased when he finds out, even though everything that has gone down with "A" has been pretty darned crazy

7) Weird chatting:
1x17:
caleb: So your mom didn't believe you when you said leiland was shady?
hanna: well you don't sound very surprised

caleb: i'm used to that. that's why I called sarah hughes university and talked to a nice lady at the school of architecture about how I was thinking of applying and does she know a local guy named james leiland?
hanna: wait, you just called up and asked?
caleb: people love to talk.
caleb: and guess what? james leiland went to S.U. and opened an office in town.
hanna: see? he's legit!
caleb: yeah, he was a pretty good architect. right up until he dropped dead two years ago. Introducing james leiland (shows hanna a picture of him)
hanna: wait, my mom said his I.D. checked out.
caleb: -scoffs- alright, you ask the computer, is james leiland related to this potter lady? computer says yes, but you didn't ask if james leiland was still alive. knowing the right questions is better than having all the right answers.

---

hanna : he's not her boyfriend he's a customer at the bank, some architect from sarah 

hughes

caleb : really?

hanna: what do you mean really?

caleb: well he had a plastic crappy pen

hanna: so?

caleb: so architects draw for a living. they

tend to be pen snobs, strictly martblanc and 

beyond.


caleb: well why does he creep you out?

hanna: he doesn't creep me out

caleb: yes. he does. you got a bad vibe from the guy

hanna: it's complicated

caleb: tell me. I like complicated.

Thanks for reading <3 xoxo.